Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Sunlit Brooklyn house foyer with limestone flooring, a simple oak staircase and a glimpse of a neutral living room.

Dyker Heights' 2026 House Sales, Priced by the Square Foot

A 1,476-square-foot single-family house at 1351 76th Street closed on October 9, 2026, for $1,318,000. It went to contract on June 1 at an original asking price of $1,295,000 and sold for about 2% more than that, which works out to roughly $893 a square foot, according to the Marketproof record of the sale, which links to the deed on ACRIS.

The house sold above its asking price in the same season that the neighborhood's headline number fell. Dyker Heights' median sale price for the third quarter of 2026 was $1.3 million, down 6.8% from the third quarter of 2025, according to PropertyShark's Dyker Heights market page. If you're comparing South Brooklyn neighborhoods this fall, those two facts can both hold, and seeing how is the most useful way to read a Dyker Heights listing price.

The median dropped, but the price per foot didn't

The same PropertyShark quarter that shows the median falling 6.8% shows the median price per square foot rising 0.6%, to $803. A buyer in the third quarter of 2026 paid slightly more for each foot of house than a buyer a year earlier. With the price per foot flat, a lower median means the quarter's sales leaned toward smaller or less expensive houses.

Earlier in the year the same thing happened in the other direction. A review of city-recorded sales from January through July 2026, compared with the same months of 2025, found the Dyker Heights single-family median up 9%, to $1,280,000, even though the typical house that sold shrank from about 1,670 square feet to about 1,340. Over those seven months, smaller houses sold for more money. The same review found Bay Ridge's 11% single-family gain came mostly from larger homes selling, while Bay Ridge's price per square foot held near $860.

For a Dyker Heights buyer, the measure that held up across both periods is the price per square foot. The median moved because the size and type of the houses that sold changed from one stretch of months to the next.

Why a quarter with 37 sales can swing

Dyker Heights is mostly houses. PropertyShark counts 2,052 single-family homes and 3,279 two-to-four-family properties in the neighborhood, compared with 359 condo units and 195 co-op units. In the third quarter of 2026 it recorded 37 sales: 33 houses, three condos and one co-op.

At that volume, a few extra small attached houses, or a few fewer large two-family houses, can move the median by tens of thousands of dollars. Sales were also slower in 2026. From January through July, 78 Dyker Heights homes changed hands, compared with 89 in the same months of 2025, and about two-thirds of the multi-family sales were two-family homes. With fewer sales and that mix of housing, each house that closes has a large effect on the headline number.

The 12-month ladder, by building type

A longer window steadies the picture. NYC Department of Finance sales records for the 12 months through September 2026 sort Dyker Heights into clear price bands by building type:

Building type, 12 months through Sept. 2026 Sales Middle half of prices Median Approx. price per sq. ft.
One- and two-family houses 89 $1.10M to $1.50M $1.32M $789
Three- to six-unit buildings 22 $1.47M to $1.84M $1.68M $646
Mixed-use buildings 13 $1.45M to $2.15M $1.70M not reported
Condos and co-ops 11 $500K to $725K $630K not reported

The second and last columns tell different stories. A three- to six-unit building costs about $360,000 more than a one- or two-family house at the median, yet each square foot costs about $140 less. In Dyker Heights, more house generally means a higher total price and a lower price per foot.

Over a longer span, the one- and two-family median was $1.09 million in 2021, $1.25 million in 2022, $1.20 million in 2023, $1.19 million in 2024 and $1.36 million in 2025. It stood at $1.32 million for the 12 months through September 2026. The same records put that 12-month figure about 17% above the Brooklyn-wide middle of $1.12 million.

Five 2026 closings, read by the square foot

The deeds show the same pattern at the level of individual houses. These are recorded Dyker Heights sales from 2026, with prices per square foot calculated from the sale price and the reported size where the size is reliable.

Address Type Closed Sale price Original ask Size Price per sq. ft.
1339 86th Street Two-family Jan. 14 $968,000 $1,080,000 1,710 sq. ft. about $566
984 77th Street Single-family June 15 $1,293,000 $1,298,000 1,344 sq. ft. about $962
1042 70th Street Single-family, built-in garage July $1,200,000 $1,300,000 not reported not reported
1351 76th Street Single-family Oct. 9 $1,318,000 $1,295,000 1,476 sq. ft. about $893
7114 Fort Hamilton Parkway Multi-family townhouse Oct. 13 $1,600,000 $1,888,000 3,240 sq. ft. about $494

Sources for each row: the Marketproof records for 1339 86th Street, 984 77th Street, 1351 76th Street and 7114 Fort Hamilton Parkway; PropertyShark's property record for the size of 1339 86th Street; and Brownstoner's July 21, 2026 sold report for 1042 70th Street.

The three single-family sales from June through October fall between $1.2 million and $1.32 million, inside the 12-month middle band for one- and two-family houses. The two of them with reliable sizes, on 77th and 76th Streets, closed at roughly $900 to $960 a square foot. Both are between 1,300 and 1,500 square feet, which is close to the 1,340-square-foot typical single-family house of early 2026.

The two multi-family buildings in the table cost much less per foot. The two-family house on 86th Street closed at about $566 a square foot, and the Fort Hamilton Parkway townhouse at about $494. Those figures follow the lower per-foot price of the 12-month ladder for larger buildings. The Fort Hamilton Parkway building has more than twice the space of the 76th Street house and cost about $280,000 more.

How asking prices compared with sale prices

The smaller single-family houses sold close to their original asking prices. The 77th Street house closed $5,000 under its original ask, and the 76th Street house $23,000 over. A one-family house at 7618 11th Avenue closed on August 18 for $1.17 million against an original ask of $1,199,000, according to its Marketproof record. The 70th Street house with the built-in garage sold for $100,000 below its $1.3 million asking price, according to Brownstoner.

Gaps were larger as buildings got bigger. The Fort Hamilton Parkway townhouse's original ask was $1,888,000, and it closed at $1.6 million. The 86th Street two-family was first listed at $1.08 million and sold for $968,000. The clearest example at the top of the neighborhood is from an earlier year. Brownstoner reported that the Saitta House at 1135 84th Street, a period-detailed mansion from the 1890s, sold for $2.9 million in April 2025 after an asking price of $4.3 million.

Dyker Heights has few houses of that size and character, and with so few sales, there is little recent evidence for setting an asking price. Each of these sellers' asking prices was an estimate, and the sale price set the value.

Timing matters too. The 76th Street house went to contract on June 1 and closed on October 9, a little over four months later. A sale that closes in a given quarter may reflect a price agreed on in an earlier season, so a quarterly median also lags the market behind it.

Quick answers

Did Dyker Heights home prices fall in 2026? The third-quarter median fell 6.8% from a year earlier, while the median price per square foot rose 0.6% to $803 over the same period. Per foot, values held steady, and the drop in the median came from the mix of houses that closed.

What does a typical one- or two-family house cost? In the 12 months through September 2026, half of Dyker Heights' 89 one- and two-family sales closed between $1.10 million and $1.50 million, with a median of $1.32 million.

Is there an entry point below $1 million? Condos and co-ops are a small share of Dyker Heights' housing, and in the same 12 months most of the 11 that sold went for $500,000 to $725,000. The 86th Street two-family house that closed at $968,000 in January was an exception among houses.

If you're weighing a Dyker Heights listing against these closings, talk with GAMA. Team about how it lines up with recent sales of the same building type before you make an offer. Explore our Dyker Heights neighborhood page, read how we work with buyers, or request a home valuation if you own here and want to know what your house would sell for. Get Started Today.

In the Spotlight

Our Recent Insights

Follow Us On Instagram